Follow us on Google News

Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed

Paget Brewster spilled some behind-the-scenes drama aboutCriminal Minds. She revealed that there were two actresses the show shouldn’t have fired. Now, this wasn’t just some casual gossip; it was a nod to the backstage shake-ups that left fans puzzled over talent exits. Brewster (or Emily Prentiss as we know her), highlighted decisions that felt unnecessary and questionable.

Paget Brewster in a still from Criminal Minds | Credits: CBS Studios

It turned out that some departures weren’t for the best, and Brewster wasn’t afraid to call attention to these mishaps. Sometimes, talent losses don’t just affect the cast. They shake up the entire heart and soul of a show.

Behind the scenes drama: Paget Brewster’sCriminal Mindsexit

“There was a lot of firing that shouldn’t have happened,”Paget Brewstersaid aboutCriminal Minds. Brewster, who joined the show as Agent Emily Prentiss in season two, left fans shocked when she was let go. The decision wasn’t about budget cuts. Brewster revealed it was a network shake-up aimed at adding some unpredictability.

But it backfired. Fans pushed back, sparking a petition that eventually saw Brewster and A.J. Cook reinstated, while Rachel Nichols ultimately got the boot.

A still from Criminal Minds | Credits: CBS Studios

Criminal Minds Plot Hole Makes Almost Every Cast Member a Dangerous Fugitive of the Law

Behind the scenes, things were even messier. CBS executives wanted fresh faces on the show, prompting Brewster and Cook’s departure. Brewster later toldAV Clubthat after being let go, she worked with writers to wrap up Prentiss’s storyline in a way that fit the show’s arc. Her departure became an intricate plot twist rather than just an off-screen shake-up. She said,

I think they wanted to make a cast change-up and it didn’t work. It was the second or third time I know of, historically, that fans’ reaction actually affected a network’s [decision]. And so A.J. and I were brought back and unfortunately, Rachel [Nichols] was fired after we were fired [and then re-hired].

Criminal Minds Plot Hole Makes Almost Every Cast Member a Dangerous Fugitive of the Law

So there was a lot of firing that shouldn’t have happened. And it’s a shame – I think it’s a really simple case of, if it’s not broke, don’t fix it, and I think they recognized that.

Though Brewster initially planned to leaveCriminal Mindsfor lighter projects, she found herself drawn toLaw & Order: SVU. She took on the role of ADA Sheila Tierney, despite wanting comedic work. Brewster couldn’t resist joining Dick Wolf’s powerhouse series. She said no one would turn downSVU, thanks to its high-energy set and hardworking vibe.

Criminal Minds: Mandy Patinkin and Thomas Gibson’s Exit Overshadows Another Star Who Quit for Another Show That Got Nearly Canceled Twice

Criminal Minds: Mandy Patinkin and Thomas Gibson’s Exit Overshadows Another Star Who Quit for Another Show That Got Nearly Canceled Twice

Paget Brewster’s journey showed she had a love-hate relationship withCBS, but a deep bond withCriminal Mindscastmates. Even after everything, she cared about her colleagues and ultimately realized her heart just wasn’t in continuing with the show.

Paget Brewster tackles cosmic mysteries in Audible’sThe Signal

Paget Brewster swapped herCriminal Mindsbadge for cosmic intrigue inThe Signal, an Audible sci-fi podcast. She stars as Veronica Chapel, a disgraced astrophysicist thrust back into high-stakes astronomical mysteries and moral quandaries.

When journalist Malcolm Feldman (Nate Corddry) uncovers a transmission that erases telescope data, Veronica teams up with astronomer Ada Park (Chelsea Yakura-Kurtz) to unravel a web of government secrecy and corporate agendas.

Paget Brewster in a still from Criminal Minds | Credits: CBS Studios

The show’s creator, Eric Buchman, aimed to explore not just science but the human psyche, blending discovery with personal introspection.The Signallaunched December 5, promising mystery, science, and existential twists.

“Heavily Overacted”: Criminal Minds Fans Hated Young Sheldon Star’s Guest Appearance Who Earned a Market-Breaking $600,000 per Episode in Seinfeld

Criminal Mindsis available to watch on Hulu & Apple TV.

Heena Singh

Editor | Former Senior Writer

Articles Published :1457

Heena Singh is a Editor at FandomWire, spent the last two years making waves in entertainment journalism. With a knack for digging up blockbuster celebrity scoops and an uncanny nose for the latest buzz, Heena’s articles bring a fresh and fun perspective to life. When she’s not conquering writing challenges, you’ll find her curled up in bed, peacefully sleeping.

More from Heena Singh

“This was a treasured episode”: The Simpsons Removing Michael Jackson’s Episode Still Stings 6 Years Later

Modern Family Star Jesse Tyler Ferguson on Why Gay Community Hated Him: “The gay equivalent of blackface”

James Gunn’s Next Big Project After Superman and Peacemaker S2 Drops Major Update

Bridgerton’s BTS Moment Proves the Netflix Show Is Against James Cameron’s Ways

Fallout Season 2 Release Date Confirmed: 5 Post-Apocalyptic Shows to Watch While You Wait For Peak Cinema

Kevin Hart Is Trading Dwayne Johnson for Another WWE Star in New Netflix Film

Perfect Match Season 3: How Did Ollie Propose to AD?

Severance Season 3: Why Isn’t Ben Stiller Directing? Details Inside

Timo Tjahjanto Shades Keanu Reeves Film: Why is Nobody 2 Not a Desperate John Wick Ripoff?

Paget Brewster