Follow us on Google News
Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed
The originalFullmetal Alchemistanime, though interesting at first, had to digress from the plot and had a non-canon ending. Next cameFullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, the anime remake that more or less adapted the whole story by Hiromu Arakawa.
However, one problem still persisted: the plot was still not adapted completely.Brotherhooddid show the ending constructed by Arakawa, but there were several arcs that were either shortened or changed. According to fans,Brotherhoodfailed to be a true adaptation in its hurry to catch up to what the previous anime didn’t cover.
Fullmetal Alchemist BrotherhoodFailed to do Hiromu Arakawa Justice
Fullmetal AlchemistBrotherhoodhas been the highest-rated anime on My Anime Listfor a long time, and anime-only fanslove it to no end. But only readers of the actual manga know how muchBrotherhoodskipped on the original arcs.Brotherhoodhas some clear differences from the manga.
Earlier episodes shortened the introductory stages of the manga due to its inclusion in the 2003 anime. Arcs from the latter parts of the manga were also cut, presumably due to time or budget constraints. For example, characters like Kimblee and Father were introduced extremely early in the anime, in the first episode itself.
The train battle, which showed Elric Vs. Bald and the Blue Squadwas omitted,along with Hakuro’s ear wound. Fans are especially touchy about the Youswell ordeal, which was omitted along with Yoki’s introduction. Yoki debuts in later episodes with a flashback recounting the omitted parts in a hurry. Of course, May Chang’s first appearance was also cut.
“There must be a part of each of them that resembles me”: Hiromu Arakawa Resonates the Most with One Fullmetal Alchemist Character for a Heartbreaking Reason
Van Hohenheim’s personality was made too intense, and only his intelligence was shown, turning the scenes serious. The manga, on the other hand, showed how absent-minded Hohenheim actually was. The first anime adapted someside storiesin which characters like Catherine Elle Armstrong and Black Hayate were introduced, but it was removed fromBrotherhood.
Fullmetal Alchemist BrotherhoodVs.Fullmetal Alchemist2003 Anime
Back when the firstFullmetal Alchemistanime premiered in 2003, the manga was still ongoing and had only received five volumes so far. Only eight volumes were published by the time the anime ended its airing in 2004. Thus, Studio Bones could only animate a small percentage of the 27-volume manga. The studio was forced to introduce original elements, much likeBoruto, and the ending was also completely different from that of the manga.
Hiromu Arakawa Was So Terrified of a Sexist Shonen Stereotype Destroying Fullmetal Alchemist That She Changed Her Name to Fool Fans
Brotherhood,on the other hand, had the whole manga at its disposal. The last episode aired subsequently with the last chapter of the manga. Thus,Brotherhoodwas intended to be a more faithful remake. Fans are of the opinion thatBrotherhoodoften assumes that fans would already be familiar with the 2003 anime.
While both anime adapt the same manga, their tones, antagonists as well as ending are different. The first anime was more serious in its tone and focused on the emotionally driven characters, Shou Tucker and Barry the Chopper. InBrotherhood, these characters are minor antagonists. The 2003 anime had a completely anime-original villain, Dante, who was created just to conclude the series. Despite being an extremely interesting character, she does not hold a candle to Father’s overwhelming aura.
TheFullmetal AlchemistandFullmetal Alchemist Brotherhoodanime are available to watch on Crunchyroll.
Aaheli Pradhan
Anime Content Writer
Articles Published :1558
Aaheli is an Anime Content Writer at FandomWire with 1300+ published articles. With five years of experience under her belt, she is a living, breathing encyclopedia for anime and manga. From Shonen and Shojo to the most niche anime, nothing escapes her radar. Her poisons of choice are Assassination Classroom, Gintama, Ouran High School Host Club and every Ghibli movie ever. She believes in living a slow life, surrounded by incomplete art projects and her beloved cats.
More from Aaheli Pradhan
Japan’s 10 Most-Watched Anime of 2025: Naruto Not Even in Top 5
Top 5 Best Time Skips in Anime
‘Gintama’ Creator Admits New Movie Is “A tool for dirty adults to make a quick buck”
Recommended
The Terminal List: Dark Wolf: Luke Hemsworth Reveals Marvel Link That Sneaks Into His Dark Wolf Role
The Batman 2: Is Zoë Kravitz Not In the Robert Pattinson Starring Sequel? Reports
17 Years Later, This Iron Man Scene Was the Darkest MCU Moment No One Realized
When Is Absolute Flash #6 Coming Out? Release Date, Plot Prediction & Everything We Know
‘The Serial Killer’s Apprentice’: How Dean Corll Was Murdered by His Own “Friend”
Is Apple TV+’s Carême Renewed for Season 2? Details Inside
Fullmetal AlchemistFullmetal Alchemist: BrotherhoodHiromu Arakawa
